Grammar Nazi

  • This message board permanently closed on June 30th, 2020 at 4PM EDT and is no longer accepting new members.

blunthead

Well-Known Member
Aug 2, 2006
80,755
195,461
Atlanta GA
There and their (and they're) I could understand the confusion (kinda)... but not see and sea (or C).
I think they're just easy mistakes to make. Maybe see vs sea isn't the best example. Your and you're is a good example of homonyms which are too easy to mistake for one another; usually, your is used instead of you're. I was texting someone recently and typed two instead of too. I don't know why I did it, though I consider maybe due to having recently been thinking of numbers.
 

skimom2

Just moseyin' through...
Oct 9, 2013
15,683
92,168
USA
Doing some editing/proofreading today for a newbie author and it reminded me of something else: dialogue tags. 95% of the time, 'said' is enough (if you need a dialogue tag at all--many times you don't). Keep your 'cajoled' and 'murmured' and 'quipped' and...well, any other dialogue tag... 'for special'. Our eyes naturally fly right over 'said'. Most anything else makes us pause and evaluate if it's the right word. Not generally a great idea, because if it isn't right it takes the reader right out of the story--they're paying attention to the man behind the curtain rather than his tale. 'Laughed' is it's own case. Someone can 'laugh' a word or two, but a whole sentence? Several sentences? Not likely. It's a weak dialogue tag--best to use it sparingly.
 

dsurrett

Well-Known Member
Jul 10, 2006
2,493
621
63
Alabama, USA
I was reminded of a problem I have while I was posting to the Walking Dead thread this morning. I never know when to use the word 'that'. I used the word twice in the following sentence. Should I have?

I'm actually surprised the girls lived as long as they did since Carol and Tyreese were too dumb to figure out that they shouldn't run off and leave the girls alone... that every time they left the girls alone, zombies attacked them.

Another question while typing this post popped up lol... Is 'Should I have?' a complete sentence?

If 'Should I have?' is in dialogue or internal monologue, it's fine.
My rule of thumb for using 'that' is to read the sentence and see if it makes sense without it. If so, I leave it out. I never knew I used it too much until I went to a writers' crit group and saw it crossed through several times.
'That' is a word that you can overuse if you don't know that it doesn't belong. 'That' is a word you can overuse if you don't know it doesn't belong.
 

skimom2

Just moseyin' through...
Oct 9, 2013
15,683
92,168
USA
If 'Should I have?' is in dialogue or internal monologue, it's fine.
My rule of thumb for using 'that' is to read the sentence and see if it makes sense without it. If so, I leave it out. I never knew I used it too much until I went to a writers' crit group and saw it crossed through several times.
'That' is a word that you can overuse if you don't know that it doesn't belong. 'That' is a word you can overuse if you don't know it doesn't belong.
Yep. Another is 'looked'.
 

danie

I am whatever you say I am.
Feb 26, 2008
9,760
60,662
60
Kentucky
I see "only" used (more often said) incorrectly. Generally, "only" needs to precede the word it's modifying.
"I only eat bacon and eggs for breakfast," means you just eat them--you don't pet them or hide them or beat them.
If you mean that's the one meal you eat for breakfast, the "only" must modify the meal: "I eat only bacon and eggs for breakfast."
Other incorrect examples:
"I only need to do one more math problem."
"She only likes rock and roll music."
 

blunthead

Well-Known Member
Aug 2, 2006
80,755
195,461
Atlanta GA
I see "only" used (more often said) incorrectly. Generally, "only" needs to precede the word it's modifying.
"I only eat bacon and eggs for breakfast," means you just eat them--you don't pet them or hide them or beat them.
If you mean that's the one meal you eat for breakfast, the "only" must modify the meal: "I eat only bacon and eggs for breakfast."
Other incorrect examples:
"I only need to do one more math problem."
"She only likes rock and roll music."
What if a person does beat the bacon?