Dark Tower - Movie or not

[Frizz]

Should the Dark Tower be made into a movie or not?

[Ubasti]

I think it would make a great movie, but it would probably be 3 hours or so. I'd go see it.

[JohnDalglish]

Hi,

Probably not, but IMO commercial pressures mean that it certainly will be, sooner or later, so I voted 'Live action', though I'd like to see the graphic novels done in animation.

Let's just hope that, like LOTR, they do it justice.

Long days and pleasant nights

[bopropadop]

I voted for live action. I'd like to see it done as Lord of the Rings was done. Spread it out over several movies. Do it right.

[rjt65]

Def. a peter jackson type treatment aka lord Rings...or harry potter type (but made a lot quicker)

ciao

[jacobtlong]

I'm sure it would be great if they were done like Lord of the Rings, but even then I don't think they could do the novels any justice. So I voted no, but I would prefer live action to animated if it ever comes to that.

[Frizz]

I personally would love to see it as a live action movie, just as long as they get the actors right. And don't go cheap on the effects. Lord of the Rings was done great justice, as many have said, hopefully DT can get the same respect.

[swiftdog01]

I would like to see it done animated. Would be easier to incorporate the fantasy elements.

[Kim L.]

Definitely make the movie (OK, so I changed my mind). Voted for animation because I think it would be the best way to get Oy just right, because of continuity (Jake staying about the same age, for example) & because Roland could look like Clint Eastwood, as he should.

[aussiewonder]

Voted no, I think it would be lost completely in translation.