Rate the films by M. Night Shyamalan in order of quality

[Jake Featherston]

Please list the six films by M. Night Shyamalan in order of quality. I'm a big fan of his, and I'm curious what other people think of the relative quality of his work.

1) "Unbreakable" 10/10

2) "The Sixth Sense" 10/10

3) "The Village" 9/10

4) "Signs" 8/10

5) "Lady in the Water" 8/10

6) "The Happening" 7/10

[Srbo]

1) "The Sixth Sense" 8/10

2) "Unbreakable" 7/10

3) "Signs" 6/10

4) "The Village" 5/10

5) "Lady in the Water" 4/10

6) "The Happening" 0/10


There.
Isn`t this a thread for the movies forum, though ?

[Nero]

Unbreakable
Signs
The Village
The 6th Sense
----------------
Lady In The Water
The Happening
----------------
The Upcoming "The Last Airbender"

------- = denotes a sharp decline in quality.

[Jake Featherston]

Unbreakable
Signs
The Village
The 6th Sense
----------------
Lady In The Water
The Happening
----------------
The Upcoming "The Last Airbender"

------- = denotes a sharp decline in quality.

I think its a little early to assume "The Last Airbender" is going to suck...but I fear you may be correct, alas.

[marew1]

1) The Sixth Sense

2) Signs

3) Unbreakable

4) The Village

5) The Happening

6) Lady in the Water

[Turd Ferguson]

Unbreakable
Signs
The Sixth Sense
The Village
Lady in the Water
The Happening

[ScarecrowJoe]

1) sixth sense
99) everything else!

talk about yer 1-hit wonders.

[sam peebles]

Unbreakable
The Sixth Sense
The Village
Lady in the Water
The Happening
Signs

Signs had the largest plot hole of any movie I've seen in recent history. Okay, so these aliens have mastered interstellar space travel, and they decide to come to the planet which is...eighty percent water! Their one weakness, their kryptonite, and they come here of all places! What were they thinking? Could they even touch us, considering how much of our bodies is comprised of water? Would they have been able to run around on dewy lawns at night, or stalk through cornfields? Could they even live in our atmosphere with all the water vapor? Am I thinking into this too much, did I get something wrong, or is this the dumbest movie ever made?

[aptpupil]

Yep, definitely the law of diminishing returns with this man, IMO.

Loved the two Bruce Willis movies (if pushed, I'd narrowly place "Unbreakable" at number one), but it's all downhill from there. He has a lot to do if he wants to get back to where he was. Sometimes, less is more! If he'd quit after "Unbreakable", he would've been hailed for evermore as a genius.

[rjt65]

I would agree in order and havea tie with the first 2 as his best--- would put lady and the happening at 6.5's maybe--

But for cable movies I always seem to go back to thee when they r on--- good twists and different IMO that all the rest....

Anything he does I like , similar to Tarantino (not them rather that I like all their work)

cheers

Please list the six films by M. Night Shyamalan in order of quality. I'm a big fan of his, and I'm curious what other people think of the relative quality of his work.

1) "Unbreakable" 10/10

2) "The Sixth Sense" 10/10

3) "The Village" 9/10

4) "Signs" 8/10

5) "Lady in the Water" 8/10

6) "The Happening" 7/10