Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Pittsburgh, PA
    Posts
    6
    Thanks / Welcomes

    Default "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

    Please be aware that this thread covers the circumstances of "The Colorado Kid" and may therefore contain spoilers.

    I recently finished “The Colorado Kid”, and I must say that I found it a spectacular read, mainly because of how it is told. The fact that these two old men take in this young, beautiful woman and tell her a story in the fullest of honesty is rather astonishing. How often do conversations between two people (or in this case, three) exist where not a spot of dishonesty comes into play? In my experience, not very often.

    As an avid fan of Mr. King, upon finishing “The Colorado Kid” I knew there had to be more. Call me a sparkly-eyed hopeful, or even just a Constant Reader that can’t let go, but the conclusion of TCK left me reaching for something greater (which, I suspect, is exactly what Mr. King wanted from me as his reader). But it was the afterword, one of a very few areas of a published work where the author can speak his mind directly without the tag-along presence of characters or situations, that sealed the deal for me--especially when he writes, “But if you tell me I fell down on the job and didn’t tell all of this story there was to tell, I say you’re all wrong. On that I am sure.” That was enough motivation for me to seek out what Mr. King had been trying to tell me all along.

    So began an attempt to solve “The Colorado Kid”, an attempt that has led me down a much brighter alley than the murky street on which the Kid can still be found, propped against that uncanny trashcan with his fingers still begging to clasp that long-gone hunk of rich meat. A solution to the puzzle of TCK may be found on that dark street, but I have come to believe that it may not be found at all. Not because Mr. King took a liberty and wanted to leave his readers high-and-dry, or even because the solution is so difficult to piece together that only the story’s master could stamp “SOLVED” on it. The reason I believe a solution to the Kid’s existence on that beach can’t be found in the fictional world of TCK is because the story has no concern with how a man must’ve hopped a series of cars and planes to get to his final resting place, but rather how the Kid got there to begin with--via the imagination of a skilled writer.

    In other words, I believe the Kid represents Stephen King himself. I first started fleshing this theory out when I checked out the history of the chervonetz. As it turned out, the chervonetz was issued for a third time between the years of 1975-1982, and was issued to compete with the South African krugerrand. The reference to South Africa sparked the memory of one of Mr. King’s stories in which a man escapes South African captors and buys a pack of cigarettes at the end. I think it was then, with that memory, that I began to believe TCK held more than just a simple whodunit. After a quick glimpse at Mr. King’s biography to see if those years held any significance, I learned that 1975 was the year he left Colorado with his family to return to Maine. At the very moment I discovered that, I was positive this story had to be about himself, or at least about how his thought processes over the years led to the invention of TCK.

    Other findings have confirmed this theory (at least in my mind), and they centralize the idea that Mr. King has created a blueprint of his craft (a web, I think he so slyly called it in his afterword) and the inspirational materials that have helped him refine it. For example, the song “Tea for the Tillerman” by Cat Stevens has the lines ‘Bring tea for the tillerman; steak for the son.’ The Kid did both, of course, as he so kindly brought the ferryman in Maine a cup of coffee, and had a nice juicy steak for himself to celebrate his coming to fruition. Taken literally, this would mean the Kid is the son of the ferryman, but I think its intended to mean that the Kid is Mr. King himself, and that he has done his duty of bringing tea to the tillerman (or at least done his best--it was coffee, not tea), so now he can sit on the beach and enjoy his steak. Another possibility is that Mr. King considers the Kid a son of his, a creation of his, and now that the Kid has fulfilled his duty of bringing tea to the tillerman, he can have his steak.

    Another of the main reasons I consider TCK an explanation of how Mr. King has evolved as a writer, is due to the focus on the cigarette in the story. Yes, the Kid had smoked one, but at one point in the story one of the characters (I can’t remember who, pardon) mentions that “one or two” were missing. It was very subtle, and I think there was a reason for that. If there was a second missing cigarette, it had to have gone to someone, as the Kid only smoked one, but who? At around the same time I was considering this question, I happened upon a novel by Eddie Dean Woolrich entitled “Cigarette” (I had been looking up a lot of crime noir writers at the time, and I’d say the luck was in the draw on this one). It’s about a man that chases another man down because he has unknowingly handed him a cigarette with cyanide in it.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Pittsburgh, PA
    Posts
    6
    Thanks / Welcomes

    Default Re: "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

    At first, I said “Eureka!” and began to fathom how the Kid might have accidentally slipped someone some poisonous material (maybe even the missing cigarette?) and chased the victim to Maine. However, I found this rather unlikely considering the circumstances of the Kid’s travel, especially considering airplanes don’t line up behind each other like a taxi might, and, therefore, he’d have a hell of a time chasing the victim down so swiftly. If he’d caught up to the man on the plane, he could have simply requested the cigarette back and explained. Also, his calm demeanor upon reaching Maine didn’t fit in with that explanation. After some careful debating, I decided that Mr. King was making another reference to his career as a writer, that reference being Eddie Dean himself. As anyone of the Dark Tower series knows, Eddie Dean is one of the most central and influential characters involved with Roland’s Ka-Tet. I think the inclusion of the cigarette is merely Mr. King’s way of winking in Eddie Dean Woolrich’s direction and saying, “Thanks for the good times--how about a smoke?” Of course, Mr. King’s naming such a central character in his most epic creation after the author is the ultimate wink (if that’s really what he did), but I’d say as a down-to-earth man and the furthest thing from a bigheaded writer you can get, Mr. King wanted his own orthodox way of paying the man tribute.

    As a little side note before I wrap this up, the Kid’s mention of “Lidle” as he hands the coffee to the ferryman still has me perplexed. I at first imagined it was Mr. King’s way of saying, “Down with Cory Lidle!” since he hates the New York Yankees and Lidle was a large part of that team before he died, but Lidle wasn’t traded to the Yankees until 2006, and TCK was finished on January 31, 2005. Unless Mr. King is a psychic (which I suppose wouldn’t surprise me all that much, actually, as a lot of his writing centers around such things) I don’t think it had to do with Lidle being traded to the Yankees. Of course, I’m not that into the Yankees myself (or Cory Lidle, for that matter) and can’t be sure that there wasn’t some mention or blurb in 2005 of Lidle possibly joining the Yankees. I suppose, without a bit more research, I will probably never know. However, considering the rarity of ‘Lidle’s across the Internet, I’d still wager it’s a fair chance that Mr. King was referring to the baseball player.

    There are a lot of other references I found in this story, but to list them all would take close to ten pages. I’m still not done examining “The Colorado Kid”, and (call me crazy) I’m not so sure that 10 years from now I won’t pluck it from my shelf and say, “Tell me your secret, damn you!” What I am sure of is that Stephen King intended this book to impact the reader in a way that no other crime noir can, and that it is an answer to a question millions of his fans have every day--“Who is Stephen King, really?”--rather than a question itself. In the sense of the Kid and how he got to that beach in his world, there appears to be no solid answer. But as to the question of how the Kid came to exist, well, Mr. King has done us the honor of mapping that solution out to the T.

    And he did it in 179 pages.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Posts
    1,200
    Thanks / Welcomes

    Default Re: "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

    nice, refreshing post, friend. now i guess i need/want to go back and reread tck. and thanks for reminding me that there's a big pile of books, crime noir i take it, yet to be read. fun stuff.

    wonder about the significance of the steak, though. once you get that first stake driven, nobody can stop you. friend of mine says that all the time. he's a builder. i think dr. van helsing said the same thing, yay, all those years ago. what was the possible explanation in the story? a seagull took it, the steak? or did they theorize that he may have choked on it? nobody there to perform the heimlich? anyway, good post, i look forward to a reread.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    France
    Posts
    27
    Thanks / Welcomes

    Default Re: "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

    waouh!! quel raisonnement !!

  5. #5
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Posts
    648
    Thanks / Welcomes

    Default Re: "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

    Then again . . . sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Southeast
    Posts
    54
    Thanks / Welcomes

    Default Re: "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

    Yeah the mention of "Lidle" perplexed me as well.

  7. #7
    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    Ottawa
    Posts
    1,023
    Thanks / Welcomes

    Default Re: "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

    One problem -- the story "In the Deathroom" doesn't deal with South Africa. It's somewhere in South America.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    climbing the stairway to heaven
    Posts
    649
    Thanks / Welcomes

    Default Re: "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

    "There are other cigars than these!"
    William Jefferson Clinton

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Glasgow, Scotland
    Posts
    1
    Thanks / Welcomes

    Default Re: "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

    Hi,

    I have to admit that I only picked up the Kindle version of ‘The Colorado Kid’ as my partner and I had enjoyed the TV series Haven and being a reader of Stephen Kings earlier works I knew it would be interesting in one form or another.
    I sort of disagree (lol) with it is not about the mystery but I feel it is intended to provoke the reader to think, in what direction this thought takes them is not particularly important.
    In my case I love puzzles and my thoughts turned to the information we have about this strange lonely death and an attempt to ‘solve’ the mystery. I have a hypothesis on what happened to James Cogan and the events involved in his demise, however before I accuse Col. Mustard of using the candle stick in the ballroom , I would like a little further information from the items in the evidence locker and as Mr King is the only one that can obtain them perhaps he would be so kind as to provide the details.

    1. The chervonetz coin, what was the date on this. The reason I ask, as far as I can remember 10 Ruble piece changed to paper a long time ago and the chervonetz coin was made with gold and there are only five or so still in existence and the value of these is very high.
    2. The matchbook that James had with him, what was the picture/brand on this book. I feel that if he knew his identity was to be erased for whatever reason and he was clever enough to use the tax stamp on the cigarettes perhaps the match book too was a clue.
    I look forward and hope you will indulge this amateur sleuth.
    Regards,
    Allen Morrison

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    TN
    Posts
    740
    Thanks / Welcomes

    Default Re: "The Colorado Kid" -- A Theory

    Hi & welcome! Well now your thinking! thats always a good step. lol. Allen I'm in the middle of Col Kid right now, and I wondered about the coin as well. Will we ever figure it out? Its not a black & white issue, theres lots of gray areas.But a great read anyway-even if it is over my poor head! happy reading! (and thank you for being so polite about your questions. Some arent and thats a shame. Keep posting and hopefully someone better qualified than I can help.

Similar Threads

  1. Reference in "The Tommyknockers" to "Blessing, Utah"
    By Aim4 the hed 2 kill zomBs in forum The Tommyknockers
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 3 Weeks Ago, 06:37 PM
  2. One "Oh, sh*t!", negates a thousand "attaboys".
    By CorbinKale in forum Politics
    Replies: 15
    Last Post: November 9th, 2010, 11:21 PM
  3. Replies: 3
    Last Post: June 22nd, 2010, 10:11 AM
  4. Do I have a misprint? "White Lands of Empathica" back to "Haze of Green and Gold"
    By asmodeus_me in forum The Dark Tower VII: The Dark Tower
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: April 5th, 2010, 11:09 AM
  5. "Earl Grey" -- Dick & Jane prompt from "On Writing"
    By lanceschaubert in forum Newbies Start Here
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: May 22nd, 2009, 02:23 AM

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts