Viggo Mortensen should play ROLAND in the upcoming Dark Tower movies

[Asti444]

I've thought hard and long.
And Clint Eastwood is too old. Adrien Brody came to mind.
But Viggo would be perfect.
He has all the qualities of Roland in his face. He jumps into his roles with his whole heart.
And wouldn't it be nice if, after L.O.T.R., he would be in the next big trilogy.

J.J., Stephen, if you hear me: Viggo's your man!

Asti

[Asti444]

What do you think?
Better suggestions?
I truly hope, they stand clear of the likes of Tom C. and Brad P.
Gritty. Real. Deep.
Not handsome and overconscientious.

Viggo. His next trilogy. Thanks.
Asti

[maidenbutterfly]

yes, I think he's a good choice.

I think Peter Stormare would make a good Flagg. Have you guys seen him in Constantine?
http://z.about.com/d/tvdramas/1/0/t/C/prisonabruzzi.jpg

[REDRUM]

Are we back to this topic again. Asti444, I respect your opinion but like I have said a hundred times.......DON'T MAKE THIS MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Sorry, not trying to kill your post but I feel very strongly on this subject.

[Matticus]

I'm still going with Hugh Laurie--House!!

http://images.starpulse.com/Photos/Previews/Hugh-Laurie-hs01.jpg

[Liselle]

I've thought hard and long.
And Clint Eastwood is too old. Adrien Brody came to mind.
But Viggo would be perfect.
He has all the qualities of Roland in his face. He jumps into his roles with his whole heart.
And wouldn't it be nice if, after L.O.T.R., he would be in the next big trilogy.

J.J., Stephen, if you hear me: Viggo's your man!

Asti

I have to disagree. I have no idea who should play him because no actor matches any where near to the Roland I have in my head. Who ever does play him is going to be loved by some and loathed by others.

[vannestjc]

What do you think?
Better suggestions?
I truly hope, they stand clear of the likes of Tom C. and Brad P.
Gritty. Real. Deep.
Not handsome and overconscientious.

Viggo. His next trilogy. Thanks.
Asti

I totally agree with this. My wife and I have talked about casting the Dark Tower for a long time. Considering JJ Abrams is likely to be involved in any films, I wouldn't be shocked to see Josh Holloway (Sawyer on ABC's Lost) as a potential for Roland. And I could be ok with that...but Viggo is perfect.

We've also decided that Milo Ventimiglia (Peter Petrelli on Heroes) should be Eddie Dean. And after trying out a bunch of women as Odetta/Detta/Susannah...the perfect choice would be Angela Bassett circa 1992....but now, she's too old. We decided that the best fit to play all 3 characters (because they're SO different) is Lauren Hill. She's the singer from The Fugees, but she had a real nice turn as the troubled girl in Sister Act 2. Yeah...I know...it's Sister Act 2. But...I think she could VERY easily play the hard talking Detta and still play the softer side of Susannah.

Thoughts?

Jim

[MidWorldGunSlinga]

You know I don't think Viggo could pull it off.. To me it would be better suited to Russell Crowe, or better yet.. Can't quite remember his name, but the gentleman in Sin City.. Mickey Rourke.. Think he could pull it off too.

[motherwolf]

:cool2::eyebrow:
What do you think?
Better suggestions?
I truly hope, they stand clear of the likes of Tom C. and Brad P.
Gritty. Real. Deep.
Not handsome and overconscientious.

Viggo. His next trilogy. Thanks.
Asti


yes, I think he's a good choice.

I think Peter Stormare would make a good Flagg. Have you guys seen him in Constantine?

http://z.about.com/d/tvdramas/1/0/t/C/prisonabruzzi.jpg

Welcome Assti and Maiden Butterfly! We had along discussion about actors and who they would play back on the old MB.(don't know if y'all have seen it yet) It was really great, and I personally would not mind seeing this opened wide up again. PatriciaA, Ashes (who I still haven't seen), Sai Dalglish and alot of others have really interesting ideas and input. :smile2:MERRY CHRISTMAS!!!And yes, I saw Peter! He's one of my all time favorites and an interesting choice for Flagg!!!

[JohnK]

I've thought hard and long.
And Clint Eastwood is too old. Adrien Brody came to mind.
But Viggo would be perfect.
He has all the qualities of Roland in his face. He jumps into his roles with his whole heart.
And wouldn't it be nice if, after L.O.T.R., he would be in the next big trilogy.

J.J., Stephen, if you hear me: Viggo's your man!

Asti

Viggo has had his quest already in the greatest of all quest stories. Hugh Laurie sounds good though. Adrian Brody would make a great Eddie.

[sKyDiVeR11]

Viggo Mortensen is who I pictured as Clay Reynolds in Wizard and Glass.

[motherwolf]

:cool2:
Viggo Mortensen is who I pictured as Clay Reynolds in Wizard and Glass. Some of us have put our reservations aside and have changed our minds about Viggo! I think he will be the right one for Roland. Piercing blue eyes and all. He is good enough actor to pull this off! I think we should think about 'Cort' and Flagg! We were leaning towards Russell Crowe for Cort! Though I think we might ought to consider Sai Dalglish's fellow countryman: Billy Connelly, even if just for a moment! And there is Gabriel Byrne, who might could be a good suggestion for Flagg. Let's weigh the pros and cons at least. Johnny Depp for Jonas Eldred!!!!!!

[motherwolf]

:cool2:
Are we back to this topic again. Asti444, I respect your opinion but like I have said a hundred times.......DON'T MAKE THIS MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Sorry, not trying to kill your post but I feel very strongly on this subject. I agree with you Red Rum! But you know they're going to do it anyway! So let's try to make it the best movie we can!!! Even if just in our own minds!!!

[parke]

I think Kerry Washington from the Fantastic 4 movies would be great as Odetta/Detta/Susannah. I think a good candidate for Susan Delgado would be Claire Forlani from Meet Joe Black. I think Edward Burns from Saving Private Ryan would make a great Eddie Dean. He can pull off acting funny and insulting at the same time. Roland is a tough one as is Jake. Mostly they are the most emotionally bonded characters. I personally think Viggo does have some qualities that help him toward becoming Roland, but not enough in my book. Still too soft if you ask me. A suggestion for Roland could be Gerard Butler from 300. He could definitely pull off Roland and if anyone has bombardier's eyes it is him. Jake, I really don't know. It would have to be a very talented young actor. I can't wait to see what they do with Oy.

[vannestjc]

Another thing to think about when casting these, and it really holds true for Jake. This is a long saga that will span 7 movies. Which means we're looking at 15 years or so to complete.

There will have to be several different Jakes. The 12 year old you cast to start the series will likely be 27 or more when the series finishes up.

Also, most of the characters will have to be no-names or up and comers as of now. As much as I like Viggo, I don't see him signing up for a project of this scope and length. Definitely not Russell Crowe.

No matter though...I just love talking about the possibilities. And I'm still not 100% sold on the idea of making an actual live action film of the series. I'm thinking it might be best animated.

jim

[motherwolf]

:cool2:
You know I don't think Viggo could pull it off.. To me it would be better suited to Russell Crowe, or better yet.. Can't quite remember his name, but the gentleman in Sin City.. Mickey Rourke.. Think he could pull it off too.


Another thing to think about when casting these, and it really holds true for Jake. This is a long saga that will span 7 movies. Which means we're looking at 15 years or so to complete.

There will have to be several different Jakes. The 12 year old you cast to start the series will likely be 27 or more when the series finishes up.

Also, most of the characters will have to be no-names or up and comers as of now. As much as I like Viggo, I don't see him signing up for a project of this scope and length. Definitely not Russell Crowe.

No matter though...I just love talking about the possibilities. And I'm still not 100% sold on the idea of making an actual live action film of the series. I'm thinking it might be best animated.

jim Mickey Roarke, to me, just wouldn't do at all. But I could possibly see him as another character or two. As far as ' Sin City' goes, Benicio DelTorro would be a good pick for anything, excellent actor. I might even consider him for Roland for a few moments. Vannestjc, you bring up a very good point! How many years has it been since the making of the 1st 'Harry Potter' movie? We've watched those children grow up on the big screen. Who knows they may not try to film so many back to back that way. I see them trying to condense as much of the books together as they can! That's always the first step in ruining a good book on the big screen. Then They may opt to change Jakes actor with every movie, or they may change his age completely so they can use an older actor for all of the movies they plan on making!

[JohnDalglish]

Another thing to think about when casting these, and it really holds true for Jake. This is a long saga that will span 7 movies. Which means we're looking at 15 years or so to complete.

There will have to be several different Jakes. The 12 year old you cast to start the series will likely be 27 or more when the series finishes up.

Also, most of the characters will have to be no-names or up and comers as of now. As much as I like Viggo, I don't see him signing up for a project of this scope and length. Definitely not Russell Crowe.

No matter though...I just love talking about the possibilities. And I'm still not 100% sold on the idea of making an actual live action film of the series. I'm thinking it might be best animated.

jim

Hi Jim,

Interesting you should say that. I'm in the middle of The Gunslinger Born, the hardback Marvel 'comic' (the word doesn't do the book justice IMHO!) and I'm knocked out. (The only Xmas present I REALLY wanted LOL).

I'll have more to write after I've finished it, but I'm coming round to the way of thinking that it may be better animated rather than live action - esp. inspired by Jae Lee and Richard Isanove, Marvel's incredibly talented artists.

And my daughter gave me some Anime and Manga classics (sp?), very interesting!

Long days and pleasant nights

[motherwolf]

:cool2:
I think Kerry Washington from the Fantastic 4 movies would be great as Odetta/Detta/Susannah. I think a good candidate for Susan Delgado would be Claire Forlani from Meet Joe Black. I think Edward Burns from Saving Private Ryan would make a great Eddie Dean. He can pull off acting funny and insulting at the same time. Roland is a tough one as is Jake. Mostly they are the most emotionally bonded characters. I personally think Viggo does have some qualities that help him toward becoming Roland, but not enough in my book. Still too soft if you ask me. A suggestion for Roland could be Gerard Butler from 300. He could definitely pull off Roland and if anyone has bombardier's eyes it is him. Jake, I really don't know. It would have to be a very talented young actor. I can't wait to see what they do with Oy.

Got to give Claire Forlani some thought, but I think I'm still with Sai Dalglish, that Hayden Panettiere is age appropiate and actress enough for the job. I think she could play up or down in age to Viggo's 'Roland'. I like the idea of Kerry Washington as Odetta/Detta/Susannah! But she is alittle young looking maybe? And I'm not sure she could muster the ferocity needed to play the cunning and dangerous Detta! Though I think she has got the cool confidence of Susannah, and the intelligence and breeding of Odetta. I also like the idea of Adrien Brody as Eddie, that someone had mentioned earlier! I think he would be a perfect Eddie in fact. Edward Burns doesn't have enough substance for me, Sorry. What do y'all think!?! Sai Dalglish?

[Patricia A]

http://i200.photobucket.com/albums/aa219/plcarmstrong/6597702_l1.jpg
I remain in the Hugh Laurie camp although I can definitely see Viggo Mortensen.
http://i125.photobucket.com/albums/p62/Vicka456/Stars/Viggo%20Mortensen/ViggoMortensen8.jpg

[BlackEye]

After watching No Country For Old Men the other day, I would say Josh Brolin would make a good gunslinger.

[mojomofo]

I honestly don't think they should make the DT movies, I love the Roland I have imagined, and anyone else would be a disappointment.
But if I get a vote, it would go to Viggo.

[neibergall]

Roland - Viggo could do it, for sure.
Flagg - Alan Rickman = perfect
Cort - Scott Glenn = smaller role in training day, some other films (vertical limit, silence of the lambs, etc) However, in "Urban Cowboy" (I know, stay with me) he plays the bad guy so to speak, and fits my picture of Cort exactly. When I read the DT series and remembered the badass cowboy he played - few words, tough as nails and such - I never pictured anyone else. If you dont remember him from that movie check it out. He is obviously a lot older now, but Cort was pretty old in the books...

[sneaksta303]

Viggo is a bad-ass... I could totally see him as Roland.

Did you all know he did an album with the guitarist BUCKETHEAD (youtube him if ya don't know...best guitar player evAR!)?

[Son of Gilead]

How about Hugh Jackman?
I think he looks like a young Clint Eastwood, and he's demonstrated grit and charisma as Wolverine. : )

http://www.webwombat.com.au/lifestyle/fashion_beauty/images/jackman-1.jpghttp://www.nndb.com/people/189/000026111/Hugh_Jackman_1a.jpg

Peace

[JohnDalglish]

Hi,

Billy Connelly for The Tick Tock Man?

Robin Williams (or Steve Martin or Jim Carrey?) for Dandelo?

Angelina Jolie for Mia?

Long days and pleasant nights

[motherwolf]

:cool2:
Hi,

Billy Connelly for The Tick Tock Man?

Robin Williams (or Steve Martin or Jim Carrey?) for Dandelo?

Angelina Jolie for Mia?

Long days and pleasant nights Yes Sai!!! (I trust your choice for Dandelo! I'm getting to VII as soon as I can!) Angela Basset for Susannah/ Detta/ Odetta!?!? Beauty, strength, ferocity, intelligence, calm confidence!!!:smile2::eyebrow:

[Goodlovin]

I like Viggo in the role of roland.

Perfect fit and perfect age and look to him to play the role.

[ilvdev]

I agree, Viggo Mortensen might be able to do Roland some justice. Hopefully.

[JoNuggs]

Viggo's a good choice, but I think he'd cost too much. I made note in a different thread that Josh Holloway, as someone mentioned above, would be a great choice.

I don't think that the movies would hold up over seven films. The books are great, but they certainly don't have a fan base as large as the Potter films, and the DT movies would be a bit more epic in scope so I don't think that they could crank them out every two years.

Also, the non-linear fashion of the tale doesn't lend itself well to film. I'm not talking about how they skip from world to world but it wouldn't serve the series well to have a movie in the middle that focuses on Roland's past. I think that it would drive off potential 'new' fans by having to wait three films until you figure out what went on in his past.

If they couldn't make the film either a live action or animated cable series, with each book being a season, then they'd certainly have to compress the books for the screen. I could see them doing three - four at the most.

Not to derail the thread but who do you think would be a good director for it? The JJ Abrams thing is an interesting choice. My reservation there is that I don't know if he's got the chops to pull of something as esoteric or classic as an epic fantasy western hybrid. Frankly, if it does become a series of features, I really feel as if you'd have to get it in the hands of someone more established who understands the western tradition a bit better; maybe even Eastwood himself or Ridley Scott. For the younger guys I could see it doing better in the hands of someone like Francis Lawrence or Zack Snyder. They, at least, have a great hand on adapting the tone of the source material.

[Terry B]

I think Kerry Washington from the Fantastic 4 movies would be great as Odetta/Detta/Susannah. I think a good candidate for Susan Delgado would be Claire Forlani from Meet Joe Black. I think Edward Burns from Saving Private Ryan would make a great Eddie Dean. He can pull off acting funny and insulting at the same time. Roland is a tough one as is Jake. Mostly they are the most emotionally bonded characters. I personally think Viggo does have some qualities that help him toward becoming Roland, but not enough in my book. Still too soft if you ask me. A suggestion for Roland could be Gerard Butler from 300. He could definitely pull off Roland and if anyone has bombardier's eyes it is him. Jake, I really don't know. It would have to be a very talented young actor. I can't wait to see what they do with Oy.

Susan Delgado is only like what - 15 in the book? Claire Forlani is much too old. Emily Osment (of Spy Kids fame) is only 16 and would be good in that roll. Gerard Butler can do anything he likes. I'd see it.

[mogget3]

I watched LotR-trilogy on boxing day,and during the 12-hours I said to myself:if there's a hothead out there who has to make this story into a movie,which they shouldnt do but that's besides the point,then Viggo might as well be the best Roland they're gonna get!!
They shoudn't cut his hair too short,though!

[motherwolf]

:cool2:
I watched LotR-trilogy on boxing day,and during the 12-hours I said to myself:if there's a hothead out there who has to make this story into a movie,which they shouldnt do but that's besides the point,then Viggo might as well be the best Roland they're gonna get!!
They shoudn't cut his hair too short,though!They shouldn't leave it too long either. And it shouldn't be blond.

[maidenbutterfly]

:cool2:They shouldn't leave it too long either. And it shouldn't be blond.

no...no long hair, no blond hair. Dark, and a little shaggy p'haps.
:love:

[PLx81]

I dont think they should even make the movies it, they'll probally hack the story all up, plus i think it'd be why to hard to capture Rolands worlds visually. Now i like the idea of it being animated,

[motherwolf]

:cool2::wink2:
no...no long hair, no blond hair. Dark, and a little shaggy p'haps.
:love: YES! And shaggy, considering those long days and nights traveling to the Calla! UNSHAVEN, most definately, and Viggo does that well!!!:biggrin2:

[sandiego39]

i would go with hugh laurie since he has that more rugged look which viggo dosent have viggo would look to young for the part after all roland had been chasing hte man in black for years while searching for the dark tower

[maidenbutterfly]

:cool2::wink2: YES! And shaggy, considering those long days and nights traveling to the Calla! UNSHAVEN, most definately, and Viggo does that well!!!:biggrin2:

he does! he does!

[kaboom]

I would go for Viggo Mortenson just because he's well hot :wow:

[Matticus]

i would go with hugh laurie since he has that more rugged look which viggo dosent have viggo would look to young for the part after all roland had been chasing hte man in black for years while searching for the dark tower

WOOHOO!!

Go House!!

[Pete M]

If i were casting, for the DT gunslinger role I'd go with someone whose older and tougher like Lance Henriksen or he's got a good cracked face or like Scott Glen . i seem to remember the character referred to as long tall and Ugly

[Leebro]

Some people pass the time on their commute by pondering what items they'd want if shipwrecked; some consider whether they'd rather have the powers of invisibility or flight. Lately my mental game has been picking the perfect cast for the DT movies. I'm proud to say that I think I have settled on my final answers, so here goes:

Roland: Viggo Mortenson (it hurts to say it, but Clint is just too old. And no one plays morally ambiguous and gritty like Viggo. Plus, those eyes.)

Susannah: Zoe Saldana. It's her face I see when I read the DT books.

Eddie: Emile Hirsch. I was actually a little dismayed when I realized his eyes are actually hazel, not brown- but I still think he's the one.

I throw down the gauntlet in challenge, peeps...


There's already a thread for this, so I will be combining (I hope) this post with the previous thread.

[motherwolf]

:cool2::oh::eyebrow:
Some people pass the time on their commute by pondering what items they'd want if shipwrecked; some consider whether they'd rather have the powers of invisibility or flight. Lately my mental game has been picking the perfect cast for the DT movies. I'm proud to say that I think I have settled on my final answers, so here goes:

Roland: Viggo Mortenson (it hurts to say it, but Clint is just too old. And no one plays morally ambiguous and gritty like Viggo. Plus, those eyes.)

Susannah: Zoe Saldana. It's her face I see when I read the DT books.

Eddie: Emile Hirsch. I was actually a little dismayed when I realized his eyes are actually hazel, not brown- but I still think he's the one.

I throw down the gauntlet in challenge, peeps...


There's already a thread for this, so I will be combining (I hope) this post with the previous thread. OOOHHHHhhhh! Dude!!!! SAI!!!!!!!!!?!?! STOP ME!!! HOLD ME DOWN!!!!

[big reader]

Why couldn't Eastwood be Roland? If Sly can still be Rambo, then why not Eastwood by Roland? Because when I read the Dark Tower that is who I think Roland is in my mind.

[ghostslinger7]

I'm positive that with the abilities of any make-up artist/special effects person today, Clint Eastwood can portray Roland!!! It's absolutely amazing what Hollywood can do with a person nowadays! Clint will always and forever be Roland to me!!! I know that I am not alone in this! Who agrees that Clint can be brought back, with special effects, to an appropriate age to portray Roland? Yes, I know that people think that he may be too old BUT HE IS NOT TOO OLD!!! I am of the opinion that Clint is in wonderful shape for an "older" man!!! On another note, I agree that Johnny Depp should be part of the Dark Tower movies. I'm sorry to write this (as I dearly would love to see Clint as Roland!!!) but maybe Johnny could be Roland??? What do you think?

[horrorchik]

I think Viggo Mortenson would make the perfect Roland. Hugh would be a close second.

[guruofrock]

Viggo's a good choice, but I think he'd cost too much. I made note in a different thread that Josh Holloway, as someone mentioned above, would be a great choice.

I don't think that the movies would hold up over seven films. The books are great, but they certainly don't have a fan base as large as the Potter films, and the DT movies would be a bit more epic in scope so I don't think that they could crank them out every two years.

Also, the non-linear fashion of the tale doesn't lend itself well to film. I'm not talking about how they skip from world to world but it wouldn't serve the series well to have a movie in the middle that focuses on Roland's past. I think that it would drive off potential 'new' fans by having to wait three films until you figure out what went on in his past.

If they couldn't make the film either a live action or animated cable series, with each book being a season, then they'd certainly have to compress the books for the screen. I could see them doing three - four at the most.

Not to derail the thread but who do you think would be a good director for it? The JJ Abrams thing is an interesting choice. My reservation there is that I don't know if he's got the chops to pull of something as esoteric or classic as an epic fantasy western hybrid. Frankly, if it does become a series of features, I really feel as if you'd have to get it in the hands of someone more established who understands the western tradition a bit better; maybe even Eastwood himself or Ridley Scott. For the younger guys I could see it doing better in the hands of someone like Francis Lawrence or Zack Snyder. They, at least, have a great hand on adapting the tone of the source material.

Wow. that's out of control. Zach Snyder is an entertainer. DT is so much bigger than him or his spartans or zombies will ever be. I think J.J. Abrams is a really good choice.

[wickeddreamscapes]

Dang, I love this place.....ok, well, for starters, honestly, johnny depp should be kept well away from this series.....he allready has way too much face time in movies, and is recognizable as crazy actor, allways picking the craziest or wierdest roles. I also am on the ticket with viggo mortenson on as roland, but we have to age him a little, and scar him up a bit. if hugh jackman were to drop 40 Ibs of muscle, he would be second choice. also, there could be a part for adrian brody, but only in the last book/film. older Sheemie Ruiz....I honestly think that mr. brody would nail that part.. As for eddie, everybody keeps saying Emile Hirsch...why? eddie is suppsed to be a smartass junkie new yorkian...emile hirsch doesnt even come close to the role, nor (in my opinion) is he old enough, nor look old enough to pull off that look we get with what we should imagine with eddie..."tall, dark, okay looking" in the book, you get the feeling that even though he is a junkie, he is in a lot better physical shape than most, partly because he is ashamed of his habit. he hides it well, which is how he get stuck becoming a drug mule. i think that there are only two actors right now who can pull this image off...Ryan Reynolds, or Sean Williams Scott....

[Vendetta]

I think Viggo Mortenson would make the perfect Roland. Hugh would be a close second.

If you're talking about Hugh Laurie, I think I kind of agree with you, horrorchik, only the opposite for me :wink2: Viggo could do it, I think, but Laurie would be an even better fit (IMO)

Here's a montage of Hugh.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-q4vIdOjFI

He's got the right build for Roland and can pull off the grizzled look that would be needed. I became convinced of this after watching that intense scene towards the end of "Flight of the Phoenix" when he is about to shoot Giovanni Ribisi with the pistol. I think that scene was almost a perfect image of what Roland would have looked like as he chased Walter through the desert.

[boathopper]

shia lebouff, he's playing everyone's son anyways

[Matticus]

If you're talking about Hugh Laurie, I think I kind of agree with you, horrorchik, only the opposite for me :wink2: Viggo could do it, I think, but Laurie would be an even better fit (IMO)

Here's a montage of Hugh.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-q4vIdOjFI

He's got the right build for Roland and can pull off the grizzled look that would be needed. I became convinced of this after watching that intense scene towards the end of "Flight of the Phoenix" when he is about to shoot Giovanni Ribisi with the pistol. I think that scene was almost a perfect image of what Roland would have looked like as he chased Walter through the desert.

Oh yeah, I agree with the Huge choice even more now.

[Vendetta]

Oh and I forgot to mention that I think Ed Norton would be an ideal person to play the skinny wise ass junkie we all know and love - Eddie Dean.

I'm surprised so many seem to like Depp as Jonas, I just can't see that at all. He's no where near old enough (and yes I know they can do wonders with makeup, but still... there's a reason Johnny Depp doesn't get cast as 50 year old men) and doesn't have the gravitas that it would call for. What about Sam Elliott?

[SkullFarmer]

I just can't see anyone in this role but Clint, circa 1968:

http://img179.imageshack.us/img179/5453/clintrolandgu5.jpg

I know it's impossible but this is Roland in my mind's eye.

Viggo could probably pull it off but he'd be lacking that Eastwood attitude/sarcasm that again, to me, IS Roland.

[wickeddreamscapes]

sam elliot should be father callahan......jonas should be casted by someone we know is a freaking awesome evil bad guy, like billy drago or michael wincott.......i mean, these guys are mean, justifiable bad guys, and have that load of movies to support them....anyways, long days, pleasant nights guys....

[wendyloo222]

I think Viggo is a very good choice to play this character, I totally agree!!

I don't think Adrian Brody has the right look, myself. I think it would be hard for me to accept Hugh Laurie in this role.

[danfan]

I may have changed my vote for Viggo. While watching 3:10 to Yuma last week, all I could think while watching the film was how good Christian Bale would be.

[The Gooch]

I like to see Daniel Day-Lewis as Roland.

[mattyO]

I honestly don't think they should make the DT movies, I love the Roland I have imagined, and anyone else would be a disappointment.


Absolutley.:eek2::love::eek2:

[Bushidogurl]

I agree with maidenbutterfly about Flagg, yes i 2 have seen Constantine, he was very gewd in that movie. As far the Viggo suggestion, heck ya!!:y: All the way!

[guruofrock]

Roland - Viggo could do it, for sure.
Flagg - Alan Rickman = perfect
Cort - Scott Glenn = smaller role in training day, some other films (vertical limit, silence of the lambs, etc) However, in "Urban Cowboy" (I know, stay with me) he plays the bad guy so to speak, and fits my picture of Cort exactly. When I read the DT series and remembered the badass cowboy he played - few words, tough as nails and such - I never pictured anyone else. If you dont remember him from that movie check it out. He is obviously a lot older now, but Cort was pretty old in the books...

I dunno man, I don't like the idea of Viggo playing the part, if nothing else than because he was in LOTR. It was amazing, but I think people would draw too many parallells(sp?), and try to compare the two. Plus, he doesn't have the steel in his voice, or in his demeanor. Like... I can see Viggo Mortenson dancing the Camalla; and I don't want that in my Long, Tall, and Ugly. It's gonna have to be as hard to expect and predict as it was when Roland danced the dance. Same deal basically with Allan Rickman. He could pull it off. He's an amazing actor, but people would see Snape, like it or not.

... On Cort I think you're just straight wrong. Cort is a ****ing monster, bro. After reading the comics, and rereading some Cort scenes I gotta say (and if you haven't seen Death Sentance, you're gonna think I'm a lunatic) that noone could pull it off better than John Goodman. Those who have seen Death Sentance: Just picture him shaved bald, and angry. *shivvers*

As far as Roland and the others, here's a list:

Roland - I wish, and hope, and will keep praying that someone comes to mind better than Hugh Jackman, because right now I think he's probably best suited for the role. He's got the steel and grit i need. He could be made to look much older very legitimately, and would really capture the darker side of roland like I don't think Viggo could. But really, I think there has to be someone out there much better for the part. He's just evaded my attention thus far. And who knows, I might be being a bit hippocritical by even suggesting Jackman. After all, who's to say we wouldn't all just see Wolverine in him?

Eddie - I really do think Edward Norton would be the best person for the job. Hands down. One of the biggest things that I need in Eddie, is the almost goofballish humor, like the dumb one-liners. I think his sarcastic, more witty side is really important, but alot of actors can pull that off. I have a harder time seeing very many people capturing that softer side of Eddie very well... which is f'ing key, because ... uh, oh. Spoiler alert... actually, I won't even say it. You know... You know...

Eddie(If we can't get Edward Norton version) - Now... Call me crazy- because this will in some peoples eyes (If John Goodman didn't) make you stop reading the rest of this post - but I think Joe Anderson (Max from Across the Universe) is our best alternative, if we can't get Edward Norton. I just see it in him. ... I dunno.

Susannah - My friend thinks it should be Tracie Thoms from the Deathproof segment of Grindhouse... and Rent. The Tango Maureen was cute, and she obviously has an amazing voice... and can dance... but - granted... I haven't seen her in Grindhouse - I dunno. She seems a bit 'cute' to be playing Detta Walker.
I on the other hand think Zoe Saldana would play it better than anyone I can think of. She was in the first Pirates of the Caribbean.. but she's not the voodoo lady. She's the pirate who Jack Sparrow stole the little sailboat from, who joins his crew later on ... Tortuga, or wherever. Anyways, she's also about to be in Star Trek, which is being directed by J.J. Abrams, so maybe he's already a step ahead of me on this one.

Jake - I don't even know. I'm not even gonna try. It'll have to be an unknown, I think.

... some random ones...

The young acne hippie kid with the cowboy hat should be played by Justin Long. That would be sweet.

Anthony Hopkins should play Ted ... duh.

Leonardo DiCaprio should play Sheemie. Just kidding, that's another one I'm stuck on.

I dunno. If I think of more I'll post em.

[jim158]

Oh and I forgot to mention that I think Ed Norton would be an ideal person to play the skinny wise ass junkie we all know and love - Eddie Dean.

I'm surprised so many seem to like Depp as Jonas, I just can't see that at all. He's no where near old enough (and yes I know they can do wonders with makeup, but still... there's a reason Johnny Depp doesn't get cast as 50 year old men) and doesn't have the gravitas that it would call for. What about Sam Elliott?

Johnny Depp is planning on playing a 200+ year old vampire in the big screen remake of DARK SHADOWS playing BARNABAS COLLINS...give the guy credit he is a pretty good actor. If I had to choose between Depp or Mortensen, I would have to go with Hugo...he is one of my favorite actors. I loved his performance in Eastern Promise and the LOTR series.

[Manderly19]

I am so pleased this is being discussed! About a month ago I was watching "The Crusible" and I saw Daniel Day Lewis walk onto the screen. My jaw fell onto the floor. HE IS ROLAND!
http://www.moviemaze.de
Also, what would you think of Casey Affleck for Eddie Dean?
Is it just me or is the man in black a little 'Elton John'?
One more thing- If this does make it to the screen I hope they use America's "Horse with no name" as the opening track.

[JohnDalglish]

One more thing- If this does make it to the screen I hope they use America's "Horse with no name" as the opening track.

Hi,

I rather like the idea of using Morricone's 'The Good, the Bad and the Ugly'.

Long days and pleasant nights

[dragonangel]

Ok I have a question. I have been very resistant to the idea of an animated DT series but maybe if someone could explain it a little better. Would it be like Beauty and The Beast animated? Or Toy Story? Dragon Ball Z? I just think it would pretty well ruin it for me to watch this incredible story made animated, especially considering it would be animated because we can't replicate the different worlds...But have you seen the movies they are coming out with? The special effects are amazing and by the time they actually get around to making the movie (if they do) the ability of cg is going to be unreal. I personally would love to see this movie made with real actors and real actresses, you can see the emotions so much better than if it were all animated but please explain it a bit better.

It just seems a bit off to want to see Roland in the same light that I see Buzz Lightyear. (Ok maybe that is a bit over-board, but you get my drift).

[kisun]

I'm not saying Viggo can't be Roland, I'm just saying he really shouldn't. He may have the eyes, but when I look at him I am not frightened, not in the slightest. Hugh Laurie doesn't scare me, but he is fairly close to how I imagined him. Viggo should NOT be Roland. Heck, even Russell Crowe IMO is a better Roland.

[JohnDalglish]

Hi,

Like you, Dragonangel, I was very resistant to the thought of animation. That is, until I got The Gunslinger Born comic book at Xmas. The artwork is so superb that I can visualize it as a template for a movie. Then my daughter got me watching anime and manga 'cartoons' (if they can be called that) and that convinced me that it COULD be done.

So now I think that Dark Tower (the books) should be filmed as live action movies, but the comics, with the back story, should be made in an animated form, thus giving us the best of both worlds (all possible worlds?).

Long days and pleasant nights

[Yawa]

I'm still going with Hugh Laurie--House!!

http://images.starpulse.com/Photos/Previews/Hugh-Laurie-hs01.jpg

If I might be so bold. I was imagining Hugh Laurie as Edgar Freemantle. The whole time I spent reading Duma Key, thats the only person I could picture playing him.

I always pictured Roland as kind of a star making turn for some borderline, but talented actor who'd been trying to break through for awhile.

And to that I give you my bizzare choice. Nathan Fillion from Buffy, Serenity, and Slither.

http://i40.photobucket.com/albums/e228/sharonGlen/mal_reynolds_nathan_fillion.jpg


Keep in mind now, Viggo's a great choice to me as well, but he's a safe choice. A role this big you might as well try to make a star out of it.

[kisun]

i just watched Prison Break, and the druggie cop guy, forget his name, would make a great Roland. I was like " OMG OMG!!!" it just popped in my head, he really looks the part.

[virtualheat]

I think christian bale would make a good eddie deanhttp://imagecache2.allposters.com/images/pic/MMPH/264298~Christian-Bale-Posters.jpg

[Terry B]

Kisun - your druggie cop from Prison Break is Willliam Fichtner. He's a very reasonable choice.

[leahannes]

Hey Asti,
I suggested Viggo ages ago (on the old old messageboard I think), so of course i agree!!

[kisun]

thanks Terry B, I appreciate it. Now i can actually say who I want to play Roland.

[ozagen666]

Viggo is perfect,but please,I don´t want to see Tom Cruise in a Stephen movie....

[Anni M]

Mr Tee should play Roland..."I pity da foo who foe-got duh face of his faddah!!"


just a thought...

[Terry B]

thanks Terry B, I appreciate it. Now i can actually say who I want to play Roland.

You're ever so welcome.

[Terry B]

Mr Tee should play Roland..."I pity da foo who foe-got duh face of his faddah!!"


just a thought...

:rofl: I'm trying to picture him wearing a cowboy hat with his mohawk!

[Drusus Barnes]

Well. Its a no for Hugh Laurie. Having grown up watching him prat around on TV all the time is off putting. In fact I really don't know many people in England who can take him seriously at all.

Christian Bale as Eddie Dean I am all for though. I know its been said before but I haven't seen it mentioned in this thread, how about John C McGinley for Roland? He's got the eyes.

With IMDB listing Cloverfield 2 as JJ's next project though, isn't this all being pushed back a long way?

[EXISTESS]

yes, I think he's a good choice.

I think Peter Stormare would make a good Flagg. Have you guys seen him in Constantine?


http://z.about.com/d/tvdramas/1/0/t/C/prisonabruzzi.jpg



And have you seen him in Fargo...he can creep anyone out. He was et by compies in Jurrasic Park 2... that Ka for ya.
:devil:
Ex

[EXISTESS]

Are we back to this topic again. Asti444, I respect your opinion but like I have said a hundred times.......DON'T MAKE THIS MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Sorry, not trying to kill your post but I feel very strongly on this subject.
Agreed. The only man to play Roland is like 100 years old now. Clint with the squint! :wink2:
:devil:
Ex

[ARCrage]

Viggo Mortensen would play a wonderful Roland, but I also think Russel Crow would as well. I haven't had a chance to see 310 to Yuma, but I heard the movie is spectacular, and Crow plays an incredible role (gunslinger anyone?). He possesses the structural characteristics I envision Roland having, and he, like Viggo, puts his heart and soul into his films. I hope Mr. King finds the "PERFECT" Roland, because if the wrong person is to be chosen, it could ruin the entire series (seeing that we ALL hold Roland on an incredible high pedestal). /agree?

[aj 2008]

whan well it com out to :grinni:grinning:

[kellye l. parish]

After becoming an avid House fan, I would definitely squeal with excitement if I heard that Hugh Laurie was going to play Roland Deschain, but that being said, I think Viggo Mortensen is a better choice (although I can imagine some of Roland's "funnier" moments being absolutely priceless when inflected by Hugh Laurie).

I don't think Russell Crowe would do that bad of a job, either.

As for the others:

Eddie: Jonathan Rhys Meyers
Susannah: Jada Pinkett Smith
Jake: Cayden Boyd

That's all I got for now. And as for Roland's world being difficult to shoot, I don't think it would be THAT difficult....White Sands military base in New Mexico aided in shooting Transformers, and it would be *perfect* for the desert at the beginning of The Gunslinger...there are plenty of similarly beautiful places right here in the US. You just gotta know where to look.

http://allaheadfull.files.wordpress.com/2007/10/white_sands_bigsky_sunrise_web.jpg

[Eleese of Gilead.]

I said it in another thread and I will say it again!

Best actor to play Roland Deschain, Son of Steven...

Mr. Noname!

C'mon people we are waaaaay to imaginative to let someone that we have already identified as another character to play our beloved Roland of Gilead! There is some one out there RIGHT NOW waiting for his big acting debut and this role would be perfect for him

[constant_reader]

I've always said Guy Pearce should play the role...

[denmusic]

no one has thought about eddie yet!wentworth miller would be my choice,jake,well dunno many teen actors,so cant say,suzanah,halle berry

[magrinch]

I think Guy Pearce should play Roland. Perfect!

[demorgan]

JOSH HARTNETT....he needs to get his hands on a great part

[demorgan]

ohhhhhhh..how about the guy from the lockout and brick...he can at least act

[kisun]

I think Guy Pearce should play Roland. Perfect!

He's too weird looking, IMO

[remyngton]

i'm with the whole "don't make the movie" but as they probably will anyways, here's my opinion. i think that viggo mortensen wouldn't be too bad, but it would be better if they were played by unknown actors/actresses. if they chose people like milo ventimiglia as eddie and hayden panettiere as susan delgado then i'd probably expect milo to explode and hayden to heal herself after getting "burned to death" (Heroes series reference). and no offense guys, but hugh laurie? he's a bit too soft to play roland and, as for the joke aspect, i think he'd pull of jokes too well; the way i see Roland is as saying the few jokes he does with no smile and a bit of doubt because he's not really sure what he's doing.

[billyboyoc]

I think Roland would be played well by the guy who plays Sawyer on Lost.

[Asti444]

Are we back to this topic again. Asti444, I respect your opinion but like I have said a hundred times.......DON'T MAKE THIS MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Sorry, not trying to kill your post but I feel very strongly on this subject.

Dear Redrum,

the movies are coming any way. Why not discuss them. You won't change that.
Thank you.

[kingofkilling1]

STONE COLD STEVe AUSTIN
i.imdb.com/.../StoneColdS_Grant_4816142_400.jpg

[LadyPain]

I'm all for Viggo Mortensen to play Roland. Viggo is probably one of the best choices out there. He's variable enough with his look that they can use him in that part. He looks suitably gaunt in western wear (see Hidalgo -- amazing movie), he could easily pull off the use of the High Speech. Viggo is a linguist. He's fluent in many languages. He'd be able to pull it off in a way that he would make us believe. Viggo is very physical; he has a very easy grace about him. He moves like a gunslinger.

I could go on, I guess. I would love to see Viggo play Roland.

[petcemitaryfan]

i think clint eastwood would still be great for that roll despite his age or even Russel Crow lol.

[petcemitaryfan]

i hope russel crowe or keifer sutherland get get the role of rolland lol.

[petcemitaryfan]

not hue lowery absoulutly not him, get russel crowe or ving rames defently Bruce Willis to play Rolland.

[shaolin]

I feel so strong about Clint Eastwood playing Roland, but that would of been about 20 years ago. He was always who I imagined in my head, but I think Hugh would be good these days.

[petcemitaryfan]

I've thought hard and long.
And Clint Eastwood is too old. Adrien Brody came to mind.
But Viggo would be perfect.
He has all the qualities of Roland in his face. He jumps into his roles with his whole heart.
And wouldn't it be nice if, after L.O.T.R., he would be in the next big trilogy.

J.J., Stephen, if you hear me: Viggo's your man!

Asti

I think Brad Pit should play the man in black for the first movie lol.

[JohnDalglish]

Dear Redrum,

the movies are coming any way. Why not discuss them. You won't change that.
Thank you.

Hi,

True dat.

Long days and pleasant nights

[BigMike]

How about Anthony Hopkins in the Dark Tower movies. I hope that there is going to be a movie for The Dark Tower. They should make it like The Stand and make it to a 6-8 hour long movie. The Dark Tower should also be a 2 disc DVD set just like The Stand was and both DVD's be three to four hours long.

[Moderator]

Anthony Hopkins would need to be in them to play Ted Brautigan, the role he did for Hearts in Atlantis.

[cwalz]

After watching No Country For Old Men the other day, I would say Josh Brolin would make a good gunslinger.

I thought about Josh Brolin as Roland as well after seeing this movie. He played a perfect quite, intelligent, rugged western type character to perfection.

[mrattelle41]

Daniel Day Lewis...PERIOD

NO CONTEST! Without him or a young Clint Eastwood the movie can not be made.

Since Clint isn't young, and we don't have a time machine...Lewis is our man.

[RsPetals16]

I too dream about who would be Roland, Eddie, Sus and Jake but when it come right down to it I hope they never ever try to make this wonderful amayzing tale into a movie. Oh how they would chop and devour it! Roland is the heart that beats inside the tower, say thank ya and Gods love him...there he will reside. Hile Roland!!

[Kitten]

How about Hugh Jackman?
I think he looks like a young Clint Eastwood, and he's demonstrated grit and charisma as Wolverine. : )

http://www.webwombat.com.au/lifestyle/fashion_beauty/images/jackman-1.jpghttp://www.nndb.com/people/189/000026111/Hugh_Jackman_1a.jpg

Peace

YES! .....YESS! This is who should play Rolland! I'm glad someone else thought of him too. I thought of it Friday night and it was too late to post it. Hugh Jackman is perfect for the role. I was so excited I couldn't sleep friday. He's got the perfect rugged face structure for the part. Ok. I guess I can calm down now. Who else thinks Hugh is a good choice! :D

Here's another picture.

http://i214.photobucket.com/albums/cc151/indyanajoana/Hugh_Jackman.jpg

[Kitten]

Oops! That was a link. Here is the picture.

<a href="http://s214.photobucket.com/albums/cc151/indyanajoana/?action=view&current=Hugh_Jackman.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://i214.photobucket.com/albums/cc151/indyanajoana/Hugh_Jackman.jpg" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a>

[Matticus]

I think Hugh is a good choice but not Jackman :laugh:

[aussiewonder]

Viggo gets my vote! I think he is perfect for Roland

[mixedmud]

I like Viggo & Hugh...but what about Gerard Butler?

Too bad Clint Eastwood doesn't have a clone that's a few decades younger...

[Firebird]

Are we back to this topic again. Asti444, I respect your opinion but like I have said a hundred times.......DON'T MAKE THIS MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Sorry, not trying to kill your post but I feel very strongly on this subject.

I agree, I believe we would all be very disappointed!

But it is fun to day dream about it at least right?

[Presque Vu]

Since we can fantasize at least, I think Viggo would be perfect!!! Peter Stormare as Flagg... now that's a thought.

[Derwood]

Don't laugh, but this is who I pictured as Roland the entire time:

http://z.about.com/d/prowrestling/1/0/2/5/-/-/taker.jpg

I'm not even a pro-wrestling fan

[kisun]

Don't laugh, but this is who I pictured as Roland the entire time:

http://z.about.com/d/prowrestling/1/0/2/5/-/-/taker.jpg

I'm not even a pro-wrestling fan

I'm sorry, but that is just down-right hilarious, IMO.

[Stewanaught]

Ok I hear you with the Viggo............but the best choice I can think of is Clive Owen! He has the hard face and I can picture him talking in the High Speech!

[Derwood]

I'm sorry, but that is just down-right hilarious, IMO.

I know, but isn't that pretty much how he's described in the book though?

[kisun]

I know, but isn't that pretty much how he's described in the book though?

Have you seen any artwork for the novels?

I highly suggest you look at those.

Just use Google, :biggrin2:.

[Derwood]

I don't think the Undertaker:

http://z.about.com/d/prowrestling/1/0/2/5/-/-/taker.jpg


is that far off from this:

http://www.dynamicforces.com/images/darktowerHCnov2007.jpg

[Rhonda_RN]

I agree Viggo, while very HOT, is too perfect. He (Stephen King) says that Roland is not necessarily handsome. My husband and I have also talked about this. We think Leim Neison (SP?) should be old Roland. He has that comanding presence, he the right age, and he has that weathered look, not to mention the blue eyes ( I know anyone can wear contacts). I thought maybe Zac Efron as the young Roland.
There should be no doubt that Jada Pinkett Smith should be Suzanna Dean. She's perfect!!! Petite, beautiful, and muscular.
As for Eddie there are so many, Ed Norton, Mark Walburg, Johnney Depp.
Blain should be Christopher Walken, cause he's just the creepiest guy there ever was!
It's so much fun to cast an all star cast.... but I agree the movie should NOT be made. It would ruin the allure.

[Rhonda_RN]

I'm in total agreement!!! Sam Elliot as Jonas... This was my first thought. Maybe Johnney as one of his sidekicks.

[Rhonda_RN]

I'm in agreement I think Ed Norton would be the perfect Eddie. What do you think of Liem Neison as "Long Tall and Ugly"? We don't want him handsome like Viggo, but still have a commanding presence. I think Jada Pinkett smith would make a perfect Suzanna Dean... what do you think?

[mraccff]

Hey now that's a GOOD CHOICE !!!:wow:

[Rhonda_RN]

I don't remember any low cut spandex!!!

[Derwood]

how about Erykah Badhu (sp?) for Suzanna?

[Tery]

I don't think Viggo is tall and lanky enough. I still go with Hugh Laurie. Just my 2 cents...

[kisun]

I don't think Viggo is tall and lanky enough. I still go with Hugh Laurie. Just my 2 cents...

I think Laurie could do Roland justice.

Another good choice is William Fitchner, IMO.

[Peter Mustard]

[QUOTE=maidenbutterfly;95179]yes, I think he's a good choice.

I think Peter Stormare would make a good Flagg. Have you guys seen him in Constantine?




Holy crap! He looks just like RF in DT7!

[Terry B]

After seeing Daniel Craig (James Bond) in a couple of movies I think he should be a Roland candidate. He's got great blue eyes and I'm sure he can sound not-British.

[Nero]

I think Eddie Murphy should just act all the roles under different makeup and effects!

Seriously though, I think Daniel Craig wouldn't be bad, or Liam Neeson either. (For Roland)

I say Ryan Reynolds for Eddie. He does humor well but is also experienced in more solid/action roles, he's young and well built to be taken seriously as a gunslinger.

[Gileadean Knight]

Okay I'm going to be the unpopular one here but I'm not so sure Viggo would be that great for a dark tower film(s)/tv series. I don't have enough supporting evidence to give a good reason as to why except that to me Viggo is Aragorn. It doesn't really matter what he did before LOTR and I don't think it will matter what he will do after. (it hasn't so far anyways) Viggo IS Aragorn. He's not like Russell Crowe (not that I'm saying he should be roland but for the example) who is like Maximus, no wait he's john nash, no wait he's richie roberts, no wait he's jack aubrey.... get the point. You see Viggo did a fair amount of films before LOTR and has done several since but no one remembers him for any of them except LOTR. (some may but I have found this to be the exception not the rule in my conversations with people over the years since the realese of LOTR) I know that he has done mostly smaller roles throughout his career and I'm not being exactly fair its just that it seems it would be hard for me to take him serious as anyone but Aragorn. Just the other day I was watching Crimson Tide and every time I saw him I kept thinking of LOTR...

[Nero]

Okay I'm going to be the unpopular one here but I'm not so sure Viggo would be that great for a dark tower film(s)/tv series. I don't have enough supporting evidence to give a good reason as to why except that to me Viggo is Aragorn. It doesn't really matter what he did before LOTR and I don't think it will matter what he will do after. (it hasn't so far anyways) Viggo IS Aragorn. He's not like Russell Crowe (not that I'm saying he should be roland but for the example) who is like Maximus, no wait he's john nash, no wait he's richie roberts, no wait he's jack aubrey.... get the point. You see Viggo did a fair amount of films before LOTR and has done several since but no one remembers him for any of them except LOTR. (some may but I have found this to be the exception not the rule in my conversations with people over the years since the realese of LOTR) I know that he has done mostly smaller roles throughout his career and I'm not being exactly fair its just that it seems it would be hard for me to take him serious as anyone but Aragorn. Just the other day I was watching Crimson Tide and every time I saw him I kept thinking of LOTR...


Exactly, and it was EXTREMELY weird watching Aragorn destroying Demi Moore in GI Jane...

[Turd Ferguson]

Ok I hear you with the Viggo............but the best choice I can think of is Clive Owen! He has the hard face and I can picture him talking in the High Speech!

Clive Owen would make a pretty good Roland. So would Hugh Jackman, Gerard Butler, and Christian Bale. I think William Fichtner and Josh holloway could play Roland, too, but I doubt either of them would get the role.:sad:

[Chaos the Redking]

I could really see Viggo Mortensen...I'd really love for Clint Eastwood but I dont see that ever happening... Maybe a few years ago. Hugh Laurie has the look for it hmm

[Agincourt Concierge]

Love Viggo, but Hugh Laurie would make a great Roland, those character lines in his face, he LOOKS like he's been chasing the man in black!

[Eleanor Rigby]

What do U think about Rutger Hauer? Too much old?

[ruthefraze]

Guy Pearce.

Hands down, the best choice for Roland. Viggo is great, and I would certainly enjoy watching him fill the boots of Roland, but I think Pearce is much more suited to the role.

To be honest, I think Viggo Mortensen would be better as Stephen Deschain.

[Robert Gray]

I've thought hard and long.
And Clint Eastwood is too old. Adrien Brody came to mind.
But Viggo would be perfect.
He has all the qualities of Roland in his face. He jumps into his roles with his whole heart.
And wouldn't it be nice if, after L.O.T.R., he would be in the next big trilogy.

J.J., Stephen, if you hear me: Viggo's your man!

Asti

Too young. Ed Harris is about the right age and build now.

[Countrygirl_sass]

I don't go for Viggo to play Roland. Doesn't Roland have dark hair? Viggo would look stupid with dark hair IMO. I don't like any of the other suggestions either. I just can't picture anyone playing him I guess. Oh well, maybe someone will come to mind by the time I finish the books.

[KennethHurd]

I've always pictured Jim Caviezel as Roland.

[kisun]

Clive Owen would make a pretty good Roland. So would Hugh Jackman, Gerard Butler, and Christian Bale. I think William Fichtner and Josh holloway could play Roland, too, but I doubt either of them would get the role.:sad:

I've said it before(many times in fact) but I think William Fichtner would be absolutely perfect for the role as Roland.

[Ducky]

I haven't read through all of the previous discussion, but... When this movie finally comes, I am hoping for some fatastic, totally unknown actor to blow me away in the role as Roland.






Oh, well... :wink2:

[Countrygirl_sass]

I never thought about Jim Caviezel. That is an interesting idea. He's tall and has dark hair, I wonder does he have blue eyes. Also no matter what anyone thought of The Passion of the Christ, he is a pretty good actor. But could he get gritty and tough enough to play Roland?

William Fichtner is a very good character actor, I have no doubt he would have no trouble at all. But.......he doesn't have dark hair.:biggrin2:

[AshTrayDentures]

I can see it, He is starring in The Road , i think thats perfect casting

[ruthefraze]

Yeah, The Road looks great. While I think Viggo is a great actor, I don't see him as Roland. Lets be honest, he's already been Aragorn in Lord of the Rings and I'm not sure if he would want to plunge back into the heroic warrior typecast again.

Guy Pearce is my top choice.

Aaron Eckhart has great potential, as does Billy Crudup. These guys are younger than the Clint Eastwood vision of the character, but that doesn't mean they can't play older. Josh Brolin would be a good choice too.

In the end, I'm sure whatever happens with these film adaptations - that won't live up to expectations. It's fun to sit around and imagine a dream cast for them, but I have a feeling fans won't be as satisfied with the adaptation when compared to Lord of the Rings or even Potter.

[SUDOOLE]

Viggo is way too hot to play this role, Let's not forget that Eddie's favorite nick name for Roland is "long tall and ugly". Used to think it should be someone like him or Hugh Jackman, but not any more, not since I re-read the Tower. It would have to be some one who fits the bill of an older, wiser, tall, skinny, long fingers who is rough(really rough) around the edges, well and in the middle too. I think it should be an unknown, somebody new that we can't relate to any other show or character, especially not something as big as Lord of the Rings

[Baz]

Viggo might be perfect, has anyone asked him if he wants to? :-D Im just crazy so I dont know, but I liked Viggo in Lord of The Rings. I might have gone over the top when I said 7 films, Id be happy with 3 films. But its up to the film makers. Everyone is passionate about it, its amazing.

[nikbait]

Viggo?!! I LOVE VIggo. I think he'd be perfect for this role.

[Ratalie]

Roland----- Nobody but William Sadler (excluding Clint of course) could be in this role. Will has the grit,
he can be caring, hes a fine actor, he has the stoney I've-seen-more-than-you-could-ever-dream-of face.

Eddie-----Milo Ventimiglia. Now theres room for change here because eddie is a hard guy to choose. I cant think of an actor who fits who eddie is perfectly.

Susannah----- I really liked the idea of Lauren Hill. Shes beautiful and Intelligent like Odetta, Is cool collected like Susannah, and I know she could be fierce and scary enough to be Detta. Plus she has a timeless face one i could see wearing 60's clothing and the fashions of mid-world.

Jake-----I dont really know any male child actors.

Jonas----- Billy Drago.

Susan-----an unknown.

Rhea-----my grandmother lol jk

thats all i have so far but after more thinking i bet i could come up with a few more tht are suited just right.

[KennethHurd]

I just started reading The Dark Tower series for the first time. I just finished The Drawing of the Three and I'm taking a break before I start The Waste Lands with Firestarter.

I think Viggo would have been good for the role if he hadn't done Lord of the Rings. I just wouldn't want to see him take on the role of Roland when so many know him as Aragorn. Jim Caviezel would still be my pick, but now that you mention William Sadler, I think he would do a good job too, same for William Fichtner.

For the others, what about Jared Leto for Eddie? Robert Knepper for Jack Morte? Not sure for who I'd choose for Susannah or Jake though.

[Frizz]

I personally thought he would be a great choice. I loved him in LOTR.

[bluzer6]

Okay--newbie question alert!!!-- This must have come up before, but other than a young Clint Eastwood, is there a consensus on who should play Roland should his saga ever make it to the silver screen?

Just checked and Viggo Mortensen's name came up. Excellent idea. Any others?

[Moderator]

Okay--newbie question alert!!!-- This must have come up before, but other than a young Clint Eastwood, is there a consensus on who should play Roland should his saga ever make it to the silver screen?

Just checked and Viggo Mortensen's name came up. Excellent idea. Any others?

I've moved your post into this thread rather than starting a new one as there are a number of suggestions already posted here for you to check out. :smile2:

[Sugar Marie]

I am so pleased this is being discussed! About a month ago I was watching "The Crusible" and I saw Daniel Day Lewis walk onto the screen. My jaw fell onto the floor. HE IS ROLAND!
http://www.moviemaze.de
Also, what would you think of Casey Affleck for Eddie Dean?
Is it just me or is the man in black a little 'Elton John'?
One more thing- If this does make it to the screen I hope they use America's "Horse with no name" as the opening track.

I agree w/you that Daniel Day Lewis would be the perfect pick for Roland:smile2:

[Drumbum]

Roland-Clive Owen

Eddie- Edward Norton

Susannah- Angela Bassett

Jake- ???

Cort- Russell Crowe

Susan- ??? (Though I liked Claire Forlanni)

Flagg- Sir Ian McKellen If they were going to make this movie.

[Drewzor]

Another thing to think about when casting these, and it really holds true for Jake. This is a long saga that will span 7 movies. Which means we're looking at 15 years or so to complete.

There will have to be several different Jakes. The 12 year old you cast to start the series will likely be 27 or more when the series finishes up.



jim

I disagree, the same actor could easily play Jake. Since LOTR is brought up so much, why not film it the same way? All at once. As stated in earlier posts the movies would most likely be a trilogy as that seems to be the preferred method of telling megastories in Hollywoodland.

[Boom!Roasted!]

Eddie Dean should be the man that played James Dean. James Franco

[nunu_chis]

The characters is good for Viggo, but I wouldn`t like to see him exacly as Aragorn playing Roland, I mean the beard is just for Aragorn! but with less beard and black long hair, that would be fine, although my mental image of Roland is a uglier than Viggo Mortensen (I see him similar to JOHN FOGGERTY)
PAUL RUDD (the friend of the virgin man in "40 years-old virgin", the one who was obssesed with his ex) should be EDDIE DEAN

[JohnDalglish]

moved your post into this thread rather than starting a new one as there are a number of suggestions already posted here for you to check out. :smile2:

Hi,

AWMMS (And What Ms Mod Said).

Just a few LOL

Long days and pleasant nights

[Spaulding]

If they make a Dark Tower movie, I never want to see it. The Stand spoilt it for me, what a horrible casting.

[Agincourt Concierge]

yes, I think he's a good choice.

I think Peter Stormare would make a good Flagg. Have you guys seen him in Constantine?
http://z.about.com/d/tvdramas/1/0/t/C/prisonabruzzi.jpg

Oh my yes......he was AWESOME IN THAT!! He stole that movie!!!

[Agincourt Concierge]

I think Eddie Murphy should just act all the roles under different makeup and effects!

Seriously though, I think Daniel Craig wouldn't be bad, or Liam Neeson either. (For Roland)

I say Ryan Reynolds for Eddie. He does humor well but is also experienced in more solid/action roles, he's young and well built to be taken seriously as a gunslinger.

Oh my.....oh my.....oh my.....yes,yes,yes.....He would make a great Eddie!
Well built??? Are you sh*tting me!! Uh...yeah.....thank you very much....:biggrin2: Good one Nero....

http://bestof.provocateuse.com/images/photos/ryan_reynolds_97.jpg

[Matthew.Degnan]

yeah i'd agree with viggo

Matthew.

[Agincourt Concierge]

[QUOTE=Agincourt Concierge;264308]Oh my.....oh my.....oh my.....yes,yes,yes.....He would make a great Eddie!
Well built??? Are you sh*tting me!! Uh...yeah.....thank you very much....:biggrin2: Good one Nero....

Let's try that one again...

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_m_0vQ6-0hFU/SH4VAf2mWHI/AAAAAAAABBE/VrniU_EHoKU/s400/ryan_reynolds_hot.jpg

[cuthbertallgood_m249]

i dont think viggo would make a bad roland
looks wise,but i just dont really feel his skills
i hope he wouldnt get it

wouldnt mind seein hugh laurie though
he wasnt bad in street kings,think thats what it was called ha ha

ryan reynolds would be a great eddie dean though
him or adrien brody

kevin spacey wouldnt be a bad flagg

[tillyn]

Oh my yes......he was AWESOME IN THAT!! He stole that movie!!!

I've never thought about who would play who but A.C. i believe your right, this actor is excellent , remember Fargo?

[Henry Dean]

I would consider myself a new comer to the Dark tower Series only started reading it about 10 years ago), but I have read the first novel 3 times, and read the entire series 3 times. Since I read the first line of the first book, Ive pictured Clint as Roland. I understand that he is too old...but WHO could ever play Roland better than him. I've dreamt that they would finally make a movie about the series. But I wonder if maybe they should try to just make the first book and see how it does? Anyone else??

[LadyHitchhiker]

I would prefer Hugh Jackman as Roland..

[rosphill]

William Sadler should play Roland, he has been in previous Stephen King film adaptations (Shawshank Redemption). He is the right age, tall and lanky, but strong. I think he's perfect for the role. Dye his hair black and you've got your Roland.
When I read the books he is the one I imagined playing Roland in a DT movie.

Just my 2 cents.

[Q'smum]

Okay, I have just finished book 2 and am looking for a hardbound book 3. I guess I will go against the prevailing wisdom, I never saw Clint as Roland. He doesn't have the hint of old ariostacy that is a part of his persona as the gunslinger. The proper speech must be used, not just common tongue. So, let me throw this out there..what about Alan Rickman? He has the ability to play the weathered lone quality, but with a hint at aristocracy. I am not a western fan, and though this series has of course a western theme, it has so much more than that. That is what Roland has to have. I think Viggo could pull it off to, but not as good as Rickman.

[elevelyn]

ok im sorry but im sick of everyone saying viggo should play roland. (1) he is aragon and everyone knows him from lotr, (2) he is DULL in everything else ive seen him in and (3) hes UGLY

imo the only person who reminds me of Roland is http://msp170.photobucket.com/albums/u250/heuchelinchen/Angel/Autogramme/Alexis%20Denisof/AlexisDenisof_meins.jpg

[elevelyn]

also william defoe imo would make a great jonas

[Trailmix]

First of all, even though I'm a guy, I still realize when someone is ugly or not, and Viggo isn't. And I think he's the best actor out there to play Roland. I would be very happy if he got the part.

[cuthbertallgood_m249]

yea i think willem dafoe would be a great jonas
good call
him or gene hackman

[jenboxer77]

Hugh Jackman!

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2008/08/04/article-1041350-02297DB600000578-834_468x315.jpg

http://cache.daylife.com/imageserve/09QY1A23rYfUk/610x.jpg

[mist2050]

I'd rather they cast an unknown as Roland.

I mean, come on - there's lots of talent out there... They could find someone with that rugged Clint/ Viggo/ Hugh Jackman look.

((LoL @ Adrian Brody as The Gunslinger)) Good God, I hope not. He's so unattractive, and nowhere near tough enough.
[Double Post]

I think Jada Pinkett smith would make a perfect Suzanna Dean... what do you think?

Neh.

I say Thandie Newton.

[lisaofthecoos]

http://i450.photobucket.com/albums/qq227/lcran22/21xxxSlim.jpg

I don't know if this worked or not, but this guy should be Roland. I don't know if he is maybe too old now or not. But he woulda been good. I've been thinking this for years now. This image is from Of Mice and Men. Can't think of the actors name right now, I'll get back to you. Hope these images work!


http://i450.photobucket.com/albums/qq227/lcran22/mice26.jpg

[mist2050]

http://i450.photobucket.com/albums/qq227/lcran22/21xxxSlim.jpg


That's John Terry. He plays Christian Shephard (Jack's father) on LOST.

Hm, different. Good idea.

[cargocult]

and Colin Hanks as Steven King

[Cassadegas]

It's got to be Clint as Roland because he is equally old and timeless timeless, war-beaten but brimming with steel. He has seen it all before and if it's not him then nobody.

[mist2050]

Clint is 78 years old and production for the DT feature/series hasn't even started.

He's just too old to play Roland.

[Trailmix]

Yeah I think Jackman could pull it off as well...that would be pretty awesome.

[kisun]

and Colin Hanks as Steven King

I think Joe Hill would play a good King.... :biggrin2:

[Arr]

Daniel Day-Lewis

[Prince of Darkness]

Hi,

If it were done as a Live-Action Movie, I would prefer Kevin Bacon.

Watch Death Sentence, which is, IMO, an excellent movie on it's own (it is not at all like the novel of the same name, though).

http://www.calendarlive.com/media/photo/2007-08/32222240.jpg

Love the revolver, ey? :biggrin2:

But still... no movie would be better. There are just too many challenges to making a DT movie that it would be dissapointment in some way no matter what.

Long days and pleasant nights

[K HjLL]

Why not have me play Roland? If it gets made into a tv series have each Novels a season. I'm a no name. My hair isn't black, more Eastwood in A Fist Full of Dollars. I got the squint down. I know I could play him.

[Kalman]

Jon Hamm!

[karend3]

I heard they are thinking about casting Christian Baile (Batman) as Roland, is this true? I can see for the younger Roland during the Wizard and Glass part but not as the older, Dinh to Eddie, Jake and Susannah, are you kidding me? I see more Hugh Jackman, or maybe even George Clooney.nah Hugh Jackman.

[Django76]

Just read somewhere that Christian Bale may be the top pick to play Roland on the big screen. I think thats ridiculous. Don't get me wrong, good actor, but not Roland. I always thought Robert Patrick from Terminator 2, X-files..etc would fit the part. Just need to scruff his voice up a bit.

[bookworm101]

I'm still going with Hugh Laurie--House!!

http://images.starpulse.com/Photos/Previews/Hugh-Laurie-hs01.jpg

yesyesyesyesyesyesyes........Hugh is Roland. I watch House every week and I say to myself. That is Roland. Those piercing blue eyes and scruffy exterior. Right on Matticus.

[October Rain]

I don't know if this has been suggested, but I think Clive Owen would make a great Roland. He's a very talented actor and in the movie "Shoot 'Em Up" he proved he could play a kick butt gunslinger.

http://img387.imageshack.us/img387/5200/de0907cliveowencoverlin.jpghttp://img387.imageshack.us/img387/268/clive2520owen.jpg

[jenrin]

OH dear no no! Sam Elliot is Roland and Brad Pitt is no Stephan King Character plus he is way way to old!

[#1 FAN]

Hugh Jackman would be great as Roland

[Sarlinov]

how about a relatively unknown, highly skilled actor?

one who would actually be convincing in the role instead of a default choice hollywood star like viggo mortensen or jackman giving a generic performance and banking 50 mil (or probably more like 100 million if it's jackman)? do you really want the dt movies to be xmen 4?

the movies will be huge anyway, they don't need star power of this magnitude to succeed

i have to say that i would have zero interest on seeing any of these guys play roland deschain.

peter petrelli from heroes as eddie? are you serious?

[MyJadedEpiphany]

how about a relatively unknown, highly skilled actor?

one who would actually be convincing in the role instead of a default choice hollywood star like viggo mortensen or jackman giving a generic performance and banking 50 mil (or probably more like 100 million if it's jackman)? do you really want the dt movies to be xmen 4?

the movies will be huge anyway, they don't need star power of this magnitude to succeed

i have to say that i would have zero interest on seeing any of these guys play roland deschain.

peter petrelli from heroes as eddie? are you serious?

I totally agree!! If they make the movies in a series of 7 or 8 (which I support!!) It's going to be very difficult to find ANYONE willing to sign on to such a big project let alone someone who is already in the big leagues in Hollywood.

I go back and forth on wishing for the movies...on the one hand, The DT series is my favorite of his work....on the other hand....it's my favorite of his work!!!! I don't want to see it hacked to pieces....it's like Peyton's Place in my head over here!! :eek:

[jojo57]

I agree with the wanting it/not wanting it conundrum (sp). Wouldn't it be absolutely fabulous to have seven incredible movies to look forward to depicting our beloved series in just the right way, just the way we imagined it!?!?!

Unfortunately, coming back to reality, it is a very rare occurance for me to see a movie, TV show, whatever, based on a book I've read, not to say loved, and not come away feeling hugely disappointed if not disgusted. Don't know if I'm willing to take that chance with what is one of my favorite series ever.

(Any Terri Goodkind fans out there? Any see the Sword of Truth series on TV? Any want to impale themselves on the Sword of Truth after watching a few of the shows?)

[cellfan1992]

i think christan bale would be a great roland and viggo would be great to

i cant wait for under the dome about 2 months now

[Matthew.Degnan]

I've always thought Viggo as well-- none of the big actors because then the movie will be too commerical and you'll that type of person who goes to see it and suddenly thinks he knows everything about The Dark Tower even though he hasn't read it!! I hate them people-- likethe people who saw Lord of the Rings and thought they knew it all!!!!

AGH!!!!

Sorry everyone for my outburst :biggrin2:

I think Hugh Laurie has the facial features as well as Viggo.. It has to be someone tall and well built like them two or... actually I can't think of anyone... maybe Ethan Hawke (yes I know he's quite a famous actor-- but not super famous like Pitt or Clooney or something)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:EthanHawke07TIFF.jpg

[turtle8378]

I have to disagree. I have no idea who should play him because no actor matches any where near to the Roland I have in my head. Who ever does play him is going to be loved by some and loathed by others.

I can so relate to this Liselle. I've been toying with the idea since i read at wikipedia.org that they're considering christian bale for roland.

the books start with a middle aged roland that christian could definitely pull off. then at the beginning of the second book he wakes up after the trance he and the man in black entered into. he is now a fairly "weathered" (???) guy in his late fifties to late sixties.

eventually we revisit roland as a child, when he defeats cort, he is 15 years old. shaya labouf is still playing a decent high schooler.

so all of this is to say, it's not going to be an easy decission to make. regardless of who gets picked, half of us are going to love the choice they make and the other half of us are going to be disgusted -- "really? that's who they picked? come on now..."

:cool2:

I have been to the top of the dark tower with Roland of Gilead where we learned that Ka is a wheel.

[Joe the Timelord]

I've only read the first ten pages of this thread, but not once did I see a nod to Christian Bale as Flagg!
I watched American Psycho and it just clicked in my head. This guy is the man in black. Also, Bale's Welsh, and Flagg once said (I think in DT1) that he was from England (close enough).
Oh and Viggo should definitely play Roland. He's the ideal haunted badass.

[petcemitaryfan]

Dear Redrum,

the movies are coming any way. Why not discuss them. You won't change that.
Thank you.

Yeah the hell with you Reddumb I mean redrum lol they need to make this a movie the books are great, why the feeling to not make it a movie ?

[Mephisto]

I confess, I haven't read all twenty pages of this thread yet . . . so apologies if my suggestion is redundant. In any case, I would suggest Willem Dafoe.

[DCom]

I agree with the original suggestion, Viggo would be perfect!

[IfSoGirl]

agree on viggo. i say bradley cooper for eddie

[Rudeboy2025]

Well it ain't gonna happen. Viggo is quitting acting, hopefully it's only temporary and even then he won't do a series b/c that would be exhausting.

http://www.worstpreviews.com/headline.php?id=14999&count=0

[Suzana]

Hey, what about Goran Visnjic?
I saw a picture of him, and I think he could be perfect as Roland, because he has this sadness in his eyes... (I think his eye are light green, but...)

[Countrygirl_sass]

Say it ain't so........:down:

No movie....and to all the suggestions, nice as they are.
No, no, no & no.

[karend3]

Actually I think Stephen Moyer from True Blood is teh best choice, he has the look and the attitude.

[JakeOfDenver]

Of course Viggo. No brainer.

Eddie Dean... Casey Affleck? Transform Virgil Malloy on heroine from ocean's 11 to his character in gone baby gone. He can be junkie skinny, look straight through a person, and he's got east coast mouth on him already. Anyone?

[karend3]

I say Jensen Ackles as Eddie Dean. He's got the look, the smart aleck attitude.

[Ilian]

We could also have Gerard Butler....I'm just saying

[liya]

And Guillermo del Toro should be the director.

[LunaDementia]

Ohhhhhhhhhhh.....yes please.....more Viggo....

[DaveN]

viggo is quitting acting...also he's getting up there in age? isnt he almost 50?

JOSH BROLIN as roland...look him up! i think he'd be perfect!

[91rewoT]

I'm in agreement with you. As much as I like Viggo Mortensen, (and I DO like Viggo Mortensen), I don't think I want the Dark Tower to go to the screen. I think everyone has their own "vision" of Roland, Eddie, Jake, and Susannah...I don't want mine ruined!

[91rewoT]

Agreed. I can't get enough of the DkT series, I re-read them all the time...so, while having more DkT (in the form of a movie) might satisfy my itch to immerse myself in Rolands where and when in another format, I worry big big about how it will tranlate to screen...

[M-O-O-N SPELLS MY NAME]

My most recent list of actors :

ROLAND: Jim Caveziel (Passion of the Christ, Angel Eyes)
EDDIE : Justin Long (Mac from PC/MAC commercials, Live Free or Die Hard)
SUSANNAH : Taraji P. Henson (Hustle & Flow, Curious Case of Benjamin Buttons)
JAKE : some LUCKY little kid
R. FLAGG : Christopher Walken (King of New York, Suicide Kings)

[GillianR]

It's a stretch to think any movie would do justice to the Dark Tower series. But then, I would have said that of Lord of the Rings and Peter Jackson did it magnificently. So, if PJ could direct, it might just work. It must be a fully committed labour of love or else it will be an absolute mess. And yes, I think Viggo Mortensen would be a wonderful choice as Roland.

[Jaedpact]

Make it an anime....

[Captn_Tripps]

You know... I always pictured Chris Penn as Eddie, probably because he was "nice guy eddie" in ResDogs, but the voice fits and he has a bit of a New York accent and attitude. Can anyone else picture this?

[scfan09]

You know I don't think Viggo could pull it off.. To me it would be better suited to Russell Crowe, or better yet.. Can't quite remember his name, but the gentleman in Sin City.. Mickey Rourke.. Think he could pull it off too.

I have to disagree. I think Viggo could do it. But any movie made of this series would likely disapoint me. Im only half way through Wizard and Glass and I can already see that.

[DaveN]

Make it an anime....

this would narrow down the demographic so much...some people just plain arent interested in anime.

[DancingCorpse]

Good call! I think he was brilliant as Aragorn.

[Bluedog]

Wow! Couldn't agree more. Wish I had thought of him, he is perfect for that role.

[SharonC]

When I saw Viggo Mortensen in Lord of the Rings, I immediately pictured him as Roland! And for some reason, I can see Nathan Fillion as Eddie Dean.

[Mcnessa]

Of coure a few years ago Clint would have been the only man for the job... but now it has to be Sam Elliott, although they need to hurry before he gets too old as well.

maybe Kurt Russell.

[KyleKarabekian]

Are we back to this topic again. Asti444, I respect your opinion but like I have said a hundred times.......DON'T MAKE THIS MOVIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Sorry, not trying to kill your post but I feel very strongly on this subject.


I agree, DON'T MAKE THE MOVIE! But if they did Viggo would be good. But not good enough. He doesn't have that 'completey emotionless' personality(Niether does Roland, as we find out, but Roland seems 'disconnected' from his emotions a lot of the time)

[Galileao]

I wholeheartedly agree that Viggo would be a perfect fit to perform Roland's character.


I've thought hard and long.
And Clint Eastwood is too old. Adrien Brody came to mind.
But Viggo would be perfect.
He has all the qualities of Roland in his face. He jumps into his roles with his whole heart.
And wouldn't it be nice if, after L.O.T.R., he would be in the next big trilogy.

J.J., Stephen, if you hear me: Viggo's your man!

Asti

[danicus]

My pick (If I had one, ha!)

Colin Ferguson from "Eureka." (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0796264/)

http://images.buddytv.com/articles/Image/eureka/hot-list-Colin-Ferguson-1.jpg

[Suzana]

I'd like to see Goran Visnijic as Roland.

Since I'm at work, I can't post any pictures of him :(

But he used to play Dr. Kovac in E.R. . :love:

[fushingfeef]

I like a lot of these suggestions, but part of me is hoping they will uncover a talented unknown. I think Roland needs to have a little bit of mystery about him.

[Ken_Kupstis]

Viggo would be awesome for that, I think, but he's awesome in everything.
Just FYI Adrien Brody will be the prey in the new "PREDATORS" movie coming out soon.

[Dani21]

I heard there going to use Christian Bale, which i'm not sure I like. Vigo and Hugh jackman are good ones I never considered. But always think of Halle Berry when I think of Susannah, but I also like Zoe Saldana from star trek. And I really like Norman Redus from Boondock saints as Eddie Dean

[Mendi]

Hugh Jackman! Eastwood would be my number 1 choice but I don't think that's an option.

[forthosewhodiedbyskspen]

you also have to remember that Abrams and King have worked together before on movies.

[Moderator]

They're fans of each others' work, but unless I'm having a senior moment (it's possible :smile2:) they haven't worked on any movies together that I can recall.

[forthosewhodiedbyskspen]

oops! i was wrong. J.J. Abrams was going to be adapting another king story(the long walk). my bad. :oops:

[brandonpeterson]

http://www.flickr.com/photos/50534653@N04/4640610988/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/50534653@N04/4640610988/

Some quick work in photoshop... and I say it works!

[GNTLGNT]

Clint as Roland's poppa, Hugh as "old long, tall and ugly"(though given Jackman's good looks, that would be hard to pull off)...

[Moderator]

oops! i was wrong. J.J. Abrams was going to be adapting another king story(the long walk). my bad. :oops:


Not sure where you're getting your info, but you might want to consider coming to this site instead :smile2:. Frank Darabont has had/still has the film rights to The Long Walk.

[Flipsk8emerica]

I think Daniel Day Lewis would play the perfect Roland. He could pull it off easily he's such an amazing actor. One of the best actors around right now IMO. I'm tired of Christian Bale sorry to say and Viggo has had his epic moment in the LOTR trilogy.

[RJErbacher]

I always thought Tom Selleck would be perfect for Rolland, dark hair, beard, cragy face in his old age and Selleck can pull off that weatherbeaten look as he's done in other movies. Looks good in a cowboy hat too. Viggo might be too young to pull off the ancientness that Roland exudes.

[petcemitaryfan]

Hugh Laurie from House you have got to be kidding me about that lol No way should Hugh Laurie play a roll like that, maybe Tom Cruise, Russel Crow,Brad pit, Viggo Mortenson I would like to see him do that type of roll Brad Pit should play the man in black or the Rolland the gunslinger,Tom Arnold would could be an Eddie and Whoopie Goldberg as what's her name in The Dark Tower Haley Joe from The Six Sense should play Jake and yes This Book should defiantly be a movie end of story lol.

[Mendi]

The magic of the movies could make him what he needed to be. I picture Eastwood (back in the day) in my head when I'm reading (or listening) to the series. I just hope that he answers the belt story in the new DT book he's getting ready to work on.

[Terry B]

Has anyone thought of William Fichtner?

http://i220.photobucket.com/albums/dd32/tballinger/acteur_william-fichtner_1246694890_.jpg

[fushingfeef]

Has anyone thought of William Fichtner?

Isn't he great? He's a journeyman actor who always seems to be relegated to 2nd banana, but I would love to see him in a role like this.

[~Ally~]

Hugh Laurie from House you have got to be kidding me about that lol No way should Hugh Laurie play a roll like that, maybe Tom Cruise, Russel Crow,Brad pit, Viggo Mortenson I would like to see him do that type of roll Brad Pit should play the man in black or the Rolland the gunslinger,Tom Arnold would could be an Eddie and Whoopie Goldberg as what's her name in The Dark Tower Haley Joe from The Six Sense should play Jake and yes This Book should defiantly be a movie end of story lol.


Hang on a minute...Tom Arnold for Eddie?
Whoopi Goldberg for Susannah??
Haley Joel Osment for Jake???
You do realise that these actors are ALL absurdly mature--read "too damn old"--to play the characters you have suggested, right?

As for Brad Pitt as the "Man in Black?!" All I can say is I love to watch Brad, but the "Man" is supposed to be slightly intimidating. People are scared of him and his powers, I can't EVER see Brad being able to adequately portray something like that without it seeming laughable. The same with Cruise or Crowe. These actors are too big and full of self importance, their casting would only distract from the movie. I would rather watch a bunch of relatively unknown actors be given a chance to portray fresh new talent, than the usual big screen "talent" be used simply to attract publicity. At least then we would view and judge the story for what it's supposed to be on it's own merits, and not for what we expect the "known" actors to bring to the screen.

[~Ally~]

Has anyone thought of William Fichtner?

http://i220.photobucket.com/albums/dd32/tballinger/acteur_william-fichtner_1246694890_.jpg

Don't have a clue who he is but he certainly has the "look" going on in that picture.

[Terry B]

Ally - Fichtner is probably best known as FBI Agent Alex Mahone on Prison Break. He's done a lot of stuff.

[lovely1]

I always saw Roland as Kris Kristophson OR Chris Christophson

http://www.freeadsonlineuk.com/_mm/_d/_ext2/35396/big_Kris%20Kristofferson01.jpg

[Terry B]

I always saw Roland as Kris Kristophson OR Chris Christophson

http://www.freeadsonlineuk.com/_mm/_d/_ext2/35396/big_Kris%20Kristofferson01.jpg

If he was younger - you bet.

[GLewman]

I'm down with Viggo as Roland. He has proven he can do the epic movie and he can play a hardcase (History of Violence, Eastern Promises). Never under estimate Brad pitt as an actor. The dude is a chameleon (Kalifornia, 12 Monkeys). Kris Kristopherson is a hugely underrated actor. I could see him doing Eldred Jonas.